Justin Herbert was labeled “terrible” by three‑time Super Bowl champion Joe Montana on July 7, 2026, reigniting a heated discussion about the Chargers’ quarterback after a shaky start to the season.
What did the champion say?
Montana, speaking on a sports‑talk podcast, didn’t mince words. He claimed Herbert’s decision‑making and pocket presence have regressed, comparing the current play to a rookie’s mistakes. The former NFL star cited specific games where Herbert threw interceptions in the red zone, noting a drop in completion percentage from 68% last season to 61% this year.
Why the criticism matters for Herbert
Herbert entered the 2026 season with a contract extension that made him the highest‑paid quarterback in the league. The criticism hits at a time when the Chargers are fighting for a playoff spot and need consistency. Analysts point out that a quarterback’s confidence can sway a team’s morale; a public jab from a legend could either motivate Herbert or add pressure.
How the Chargers responded
Head coach Kellen Moore addressed the comments in a post‑game press conference after a 24‑17 loss to the Denver Broncos on September 3. He defended Herbert, highlighting a 320‑yard passing total and two touchdown throws despite the interception. Moore emphasized that the team’s offensive line injuries have limited Herbert’s ability to execute his usual quick‑release game plan.
What’s next for the quarterback?
The Chargers have a bye week on October 12, giving Herbert a chance to regroup. Sources close to the locker room say he’s reviewing film with the offensive coordinator Mike McCoy, focusing on reading blitzes and improving his third‑down efficiency. If Herbert can raise his passer rating above 95 in the next three games, the narrative may shift from doubt to redemption.
Fan reaction and broader impact
Social media erupted after Montana’s remarks. Some fans rallied behind Herbert, using the hashtag #HerbertNeverQuit, while others echoed the former champion’s sentiment, demanding a change at the helm. Sportswriters note that such high‑profile criticism can influence future contract negotiations and even affect Hall‑of‑Fame discussions for both players.
The debate over Justin Herbert’s performance is far from settled. As the Chargers head into the mid‑season stretch, every snap will be scrutinized, and the quarterback’s ability to silence doubters will define his legacy.