NFL insiders keep praising Justin Herbert even after another Chargers playoff exit.

What’s the latest on Justin Herbert?

NFL analysts still can’t quit Justin Herbert despite the Los Angeles Chargers’ latest playoff failure. The 26-year-old quarterback remains a top-tier talent in their eyes, even as his team’s postseason struggles continue.

Herbert’s 2025 season ended in January with a playoff loss to the Kansas City Chiefs. The 24–17 defeat marked the Chargers’ fourth straight postseason exit under his tenure. Yet insiders still cite his arm talent and production as reasons for optimism.

Why do insiders still love Justin Herbert?

Analysts point to Herbert’s 4,739 passing yards and 31 touchdowns in 2025 as proof he’s elite. His 93.1 passer rating ranked sixth in the NFL last season. Even with the playoff heartbreak, his raw numbers keep him in the QB1 conversation.

But the playoff losses—including a 24–17 defeat to Kansas City in January—raise questions. Herbert’s 0–3 record in playoff games under center fuels skepticism about his big-game reputation. Still, insiders argue his tools outweigh the results so far.

What’s next for Justin Herbert and the Chargers?

The Chargers are expected to add weapons this offseason to help Herbert cut down on turnovers. His 13 interceptions in 2025 were his most since 2022. A stronger supporting cast could ease the burden on his shoulders.

Herbert’s contract situation also looms. The Chargers hold his fifth-year option, but his long-term future in Los Angeles remains unsettled. Insiders say his play will dictate whether he stays or goes.

How do rivals view Justin Herbert?

Rival QBs still respect Herbert’s arm strength and improvisational skills. Patrick Mahomes called him “a problem” after their January playoff matchup. But the lack of postseason wins keeps him outside the true elite tier in some circles.

The narrative around Herbert now splits between his undeniable talent and the unanswered questions about his ability to lead a deep playoff run. Until he changes that, the debate won’t fade.

The Chargers’ 2026 draft plans could reshape Herbert’s path. If Los Angeles adds a top receiver, his regular-season impact may rise further. But the playoff monkey stays on his back until he delivers in January.